Wednesday, August 4, 2010

In response to US GOV Today's post

In response to US GOV Today's post, Get Out of My Yard:

There is indeed a lot of criticism surrounding this piece of Arizona legislature. I can see how it could be perceived as racist because of the nature of requesting citizenship proof. However, if you read the bill, it simply says that officers can request citizenship status when it is practical for the situation. The bill says nothing about skin color.

You also state, "I feel that if someone cannot understand a single word of the English language they should not be hired period." Well, coming from my experience with LEGAL Latinos that speak only Spanish, barring someone from employment because they can't speak English is ridiculous. In the restaurant I work at, many of the cooks speak only broken English (at best) and are a very valuable asset to the business. Many of them support their (also legal) families with the money they earn at the restaurant, cooking and cleaning things that no one else has the work ethic to do. And they do it well. So I encourage you to re-think your statement about language being a prerequisite to work.

I also have to disagree with what you say about illegals not reaping the benefits of legal citizens. Sure, they may not be using the same government aid programs that other citizens are, but living in America for most illegals means experiencing safety from drug wars, superior education, and better work compensation.

No comments: